Vancouver Geomancy

  • Posted by
  • Filed in City
  • July 9, 2008


View Larger Map

Something I've been toying with as I wander these streets in July is the idea, as new-agey as it sounds, that the physical environment determines the character of neighbourhoods and regional relationships, and that this is manifested in distinctive patterns of energy. This includes not only the geomorphological processes at work, but also the processes of commerce: the relationships between cargo and consumer; work/home, rich and poor. The processes, both ephemeral and tangible, that shape this little fishing village turned yuppie resort.

How, for example, did Strathcona and the West End succesfully dodge gentrification, while Coal Harbour and Yaletown were consumed almost whole? How is it that the DTES came to be, in all its violent glory, while Kitsilano/Shaugnessy, and Kerrisdale bask in somnambulant bliss? How can we shape these historic, geographic, economic, and cultural forces to create a more livable city?

070908_geomancy1.jpgOf course this idea is nothing new. Feng Shui, as we all must surely know by know, is the reason for example, so many Chinese-Canadians choose to live in Richmond, as they see it as the tail of the dragon, a safe place to live. Dominican and False Dominican alike wandered from door to door in mediaeval Europe. The Situationists International, inspired by the likes of Walter Benjamin and other flaneurs made it political, and scrawled slogans on walls like "To wander is to live", and "The new beauty will be of situtations, proverbial and lived". The Vancouver School of artists became acutely aware of these aforementioned relationships, searching for "difficult beauty" in the city's wide open spaces. Meanwhile, today's digital photographer can find themselves immersed in the urban tapestry, recording every slight twitch of the city's restless legs. 070908_geomancy2.jpg

Vancouver is unique in its utopian newness, as forces were at work to shape the city before it even was cleared of timber. Competing landowners wrestled over the direction Vancouver was to develop; a group of Victorians saw eastward expansion to the capital of New Westminster and towards the former proposed site of the CN Terminus in Port Moody, while the CN was given most of the what is now downtown peninsula and West End as a bribe to build the Terminus on the new Granville Townsite. As the book Unfinished Business testifies, "the effect is a persistent and primordial tension between the expanding forms of the built environment and the natural plane of the horizon" that can be deduced from street photography throughout time which in turn "inform our historical understanding of a city's relationship to the frontier, but also allude to the formation of social types and urban perspectives".

070908_geomancy3'.jpg

My hope is to do something similar to what Jeff Otto O'Brien is doing, but in text form. For example, there is a great walk that runs from Stanley Park, along Coal Harbour, through Gastown, Chinatown, Cracktown, Sportsland (under Georgia Viaduct), Hogans Alley, Prior Street, Strathcona Community Gardens, and finally the railway tracks. You get a real cross section of emotions, if you are open enough, from the chaos of tourist filled Gastown to the utter tranquility of Strathcona. Stay tuned.

Reader Reviews and Comments

Submit a Review or Comment

i am up for a live 'text walk' childcare-willing, you organizing one? sounds great!

Posted by: Roland Tanglao at July 9, 2008 12:13 PM | Quote Comment

What kind of camera set-up was that middle shot w/ the cranes in the background taken with?!? Nice!

Posted by: anon at July 9, 2008 12:57 PM | Quote Comment

Is it really gentrification in Yaletown and Coal Harbour if there was never any displacement? Those two neighbourhoods were created from scratch, basically instantaneously. I suppose the industry in both locations (for many reasons).

Posted by: bill at July 9, 2008 2:07 PM | Quote Comment

(cont.)
I suppose the industry was displaced - but it left on its own accord for a variety of reasons. The condos didn't push out the sawmills.

Posted by: bill at July 9, 2008 2:09 PM | Quote Comment

With Coal Harbour I would agree, although gentrification should apply to any rapid densification of a pre-existing area in such a way as to homogenize and sanitize it for post modern living. In the case of Yaletown, it very well could have led to a massive shortage of office and light industrial space in Vancouver. Look at Surrey, Burnaby, Richmond, etc and you'll see that a lot of office space and high tech parks are opening up. Downtown Vancouver is a bedroom community.

Posted by: sean Orr at July 9, 2008 2:33 PM | Quote Comment

The shot was taken with a Canon sd600 Elph. Very cheap. It was just really nice light...

Posted by: sean Orr at July 9, 2008 2:34 PM | Quote Comment

the west end didn't avoid gentrification. it just got old. back in the sixties the west end was a souless collection of apartment buildings, having newly replaced the old mansions from when it was the ritzy place to live. it became a good place to live over time.

i wouldn't want to live in yaletown now, but maybe in fifty years, when it's had a chance to diversify and deteriorate, it'll be the new cool place to live... assuming that the condos aren't torn down and replaced with shiny new condos.

Posted by: nigel at July 11, 2008 6:33 PM | Quote Comment

Post a comment

Remember Me?

Email This Entry

Email 'Vancouver Geomancy' to: Message (optional):
Your email address:

Please type the verification code displayed in the image:

Information collected on this page will only be used to send an email on
your behalf and will not be used for any marketing purposes.
Disclaimer: Comments and blog entries represent the viewpoints of the individual and no one else.